Puffy Vs Casper

Updated October, 2020
Advertiser Disclosure
Get $200 off, purchases over $1000!

Saatva is our top pick for the #1 mattress in 2020! They're a luxury bed shipped directly to your door (with white-glove delivery), and over 50,000 reviews.

Check Price →

Puffy offers high-quality foam mattresses with features like Adapting Dual Cloud foam layers and ClimateComfort™. Their mattresses are OEKO-TEX®️ and CertiPUR-US® certified. Casper was established in 2014 and popularized the bed-in-a-box concept, which changed the way mattresses ship. We've compiled a side-by-side comparison of Puffy and Casper to see which mattress is the right choice for you!

Puffy & Casper at a glance

Puffy has received awards like 2020 Best mattress. They use CertiPUR-US® certified materials and make their mattresses in the USA. They're OEKO-TEX®️

standard 100 certified as well. Puffy puts a large focus on quality, so they only compress their mattresses in small batches. This means your mattress spends only 1-2 weeks in a box, at the most. Puffy has a life-tme warranty with their mattresses and give you over a month to try your mattress risk-free.

Casper is a fairly young brand, established in 2014. They're known for popularizing the bed-in-a-box shipping method and sell foam and hybrid luxury mattresses. Some special features they offer in their mattresses include AirScape™ (a breathable foam), and Zoned Support™.

While offering a well-made foam mattresses, is Puffy really worth the hype? Let's take a look at Puffy and their closest competitor to see which mattress brand reigns supreme.

Competitor #1: Puffy

Puffy has 3 high-quality, luxury foam mattresses to choose from. Each one is CertiPUR-US® certified.

Puffy Mattress

The Puffy mattress is designed to feel like you're sleeping on a cloud. This mattress has a Cooling Gel Cloud layer that's breathable, and helps to regulate temperature. The ClimateComfort™ layer acts as a temperature stabilizer. Overall, this a great mattress for hot sleepers.

  • Starts at $495 for a Twin and goes up to $1050 for a California King.

Puffy Lux Mattress

This mattress has Cooling Cloud & Body Adapting Dual Cloud foam layers that are combined to ease back pain and strains. The Core Support Layer is designed for optimal spine alignment. This mattress is great for people who suffer from pain or poor alignment.

  • Starts at $1145 for a Twin and goes up to $1695 for a California King.

Puffy Royal Mattress

This mattress contours to the shape of your body, but has a slight bounce. This extra bounce relieves pressure points. The top layer is made of gel- cooling beads and the base is  made with advanced airflow technology. This reduces the amount of heat being retained in your mattress. A great choice for people who sleep hot and need extra back support.

  • Starts at $1345 for a Twin and goes up to $2695 for a California King.

Competitor #2: Casper

Casper has 3 high-quality foam and hybrid mattresses. Casper's researchers, designers, and engineers at Casper Labs spend their waking hours studying sleep and creating products based on real customer needs and feedback. The result? The most innovative sleep products ever dreamed up.


Sleepers of all kinds who want both support and cooling are likely to enjoy this mattress. This mattress features 3 zones of support for all-night comfort. Perforated breathable foam keeps you cool at night. It's available as all-foam or a hybrid. Each mattress cover is made with up to 57 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $595 for a Twin and goes up to $1295 for a California King.

Nova Hyrbid

This is the perfect mattress for those who want a plush top layer without sacrificing support and cooling. It features plush comfort for the coziest sleep, 7 zones of support for proper spinal alignment, and 2 layers of perforated breathable foam. The hybrid design combines foam and springs for added lift and airflow. Each mattress cover is made with up to 70 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $1095 for a Twin and goes up to $2295 for a California King.

Wave Hybrid

This model is made for people who have aches and pains and want maximum support with cooling features. Continuous ergonomic zones with gel pods relieve aches and pains and 3 layers of perforated breathable foam with cooling gel help you sleep cool. Each mattress cover is made with up to 121 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $1495 for a Twin and goes up to $2295 for a California King.

Side-By-Side Comparison

Construction (original models)
Airscape™ Breathable Foam
Cooling Cloud Foam
Zoned Support™ Memory Foam
Climate Comfort Foam
Durable Foam Base Layer
Firm Core Foam
Price Range
FREE (except HI and AK)
FREE (except HI and AK)
Sleep Trial
100-night trial
101-night trial
10-year warranty
Lifetime warranty

Puffy and Casper offer foam mattresses that provide supportive comfort. Some main differences between these two are their sleep trial, and warranty. So, which should you choose?

Puffy's original mattress is great for all sleeping types and has climate-adaptive materials. We recommend it the most for hot sleepers, due to its many cooling features. It does a great job at regulating your temperature and still gives you proper spine support. Puffy's mattresses come with a lifetime warranty, one of only a handful of companies that offer this in the industry.

Casper's original model is great for side sleepers and hot sleepers. Airscape™ breathable foam provides better ventilation, which keeps the top layer cooler for a comfortable sleep. Additionally, if you suffer from back pain or have sore points that need proper support, Casper's firm core foam provides excellent relief.

How To Choose The Right Mattress

First off, if your current mattress is 7-10 years old and you're experiencing more body aches and pains, it's time to buy a new mattress. Getting a good night's sleep is essential in maintaining a healthy body and mind. Choosing the right mattress doesn't have to be a hassle, follow these guidelines to find the right one for you!

  • Choose a mattress based on your individual needs. If you're looking for plushier support that adapts to your body's shape, a memory foam mattress is the best choice. If you want a more firm, traditional, feel an innerspring mattress is what you want. For the best of both worlds, get a hybrid mattress.
  • Get proper lumbar support. The majority of your body weight is positioned in what is called the "center third" of the mattress. Find a mattress that has excellent lumbar support as it prevents and alleviates pain in the back and hips. If you're looking for extra support, Saatva's unique lumbar zone technology might be the best fit.
  • Find a mattress with a long in-home trial. You want to be able to test your mattress over an extended period of time to really make sure this is the right one for you. Look for a company that offers a risk-free in-home sleep trial. Nectar offers a 365-day trial. IDLE Sleep offers a full 18-month trial (the longest in the industry).

Where can I find a great, affordable mattress (in 2020)?

If you're searching for an affordable mattress that offers a wide range of comfort and pressure relief, we've compiled a list of mattresses for you to consider:

  1. Saatva Mattress - fantastic for all sleep positions, and is rated our Best Mattress of 2020.
  2. Idle Sleep - great for responsive pressure relief.
  3. Puffy - feels like you're sleeping on a cool cloud (at a good price).
  4. Ghostbed - beautiful, plush cover w/ aerated latex and healthy spinal alignment.
  5. Winkbeds - 3-stage back relief with free shipping and returns.

Read our short, well-researched 10 Best Mattresses of 2020, here. Our ultimate goal is to help you pick your perfect mattress online, today!

Get $200 off, purchases over $1000!

Saatva is our top pick for the #1 mattress in 2020! They're a luxury bed shipped directly to your door (with white-glove delivery), and over 50,000 reviews.

Check Price →