Casper Vs Tempur-Pedic

Updated October, 2020
Advertiser Disclosure
Get $200 off, purchases over $1000!

Saatva is our top pick for the #1 mattress in 2020! They're a luxury bed shipped directly to your door (with white-glove delivery), and over 50,000 reviews.

Check Price →

Casper has made themselves synonymous with the term "mattress-in-a-box." We've compiled a side-by-side comparison of Casper's top competitor, Tempur-Pedic, to see which mattress is the right choice for you. Tempur-Pedic is a well-known name in the mattress industry for their superior memory foam mattresses.

Casper & Tempur-Pedic at a glance

Casper is known for their mattresses that come in boxes, delivered to your door. Their prices aren't too high and the mattresses are great quality. Casper also puts a major emphasis on the sustainability of their beds. Getting a bed-in-a-box cuts out the middle man and delivery and assembly fees. But what if you have a specific support need or can't handle assembling a bed by yourself?

Let's take a look at Casper and their closest competitor to see which mattress brand reigns supreme.

Competitor #1: Casper

Casper is the brand you think of when someone says "mattress-in-a-box." They are eco-friendly and offer the option to try their beds in one of their showrooms in most metropolitan areas. Over 70% of people who have slept on a Casper say it improved their sleep. They have 3 models:

Original Casper

A great all-around mattress, offering both support and cooling. The mattress helps with spinal alignment with 3 different support zones. The softer foam around the neck and upper back provide relief, while firm foam around the waist and hips align the spine. Comes in hybrid or an all-foam option.

  • Starts at $595 for a Twin and goes up to $1,295 for a California King

Wave Hybrid

The Wave Hybrid offers the maximum support for pressure points using gel pods to keep your spine in line. The Waves keeps all the same cooling advances as the Original just with more support. 90% of sleepers reported less back pain using the Wave.

  • Starts at $1,495 for a twin and goes up to $2,995 for a California King.

Nova Hybrid

Casper's newest mattress, the Nova offers plush comfort without sacrificing support. 7 different support zones help keep your spine aligned.

  • Starts at $1,095 for a Twin and goes up to $2,295 for a California King.

Competitor #2: Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic is a name recognized by most people. They use one of a kind materials and are continually innovating to find the best sleep possible. They have a bed for everyone, no matter how prefer to sleep. Over 95% of people recommend their Tempur-Pedic Mattress. The biggest difference between Tempur-Pedic and Bob-O-Pedic is their materials and price. Here are Tempur-Pedic's models.

TEMPUR-breeze

This mattress features a washable cover that is easy to zip on and off, Tempur-Pedic's PureCool Phase Change Material, and Tempur-CM+. This advanced Technology means that you're going to be comfortable and cool all through the night.

  • Starts at $4,199 for a Twin Long and goes up to $8,399 for a Split California King

TEMPUR-Cloud

If you're looking for a bed-in-a-box with all of Tempur-Pedic's innovations this is the bed for you. This mattress has all the support you could need, along with plenty of moisture-wicking and softness.

  • Starts at $1,699 for a twin and goes to $2,399 for a California King

TEMPUR-Adapt

This mattress has a cover that is cool to the touch and offers plenty of adaptability by having a support layer and a comfort layer. The hybrid option even provides innerspring coils to more support.

  • Starts at $1,699 for a twin and goes to $3,398 for a split California King

TEMPUR-ProAdapt

Just like the Adapt, this mattress has the cooling cover with an antimicrobial treatment and a support level and a comfort level. The comfort level of the ProAdapt is thicker than the Adapt.

  • Starts at $2,499 for a twin and goes to $4,998 for a split California King.

TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt

This mattress offers all the perks of the TEMPUR-Adapt and ProAdapt with more features on top. The layers are tighter and link together in more places, providing more conforming and more support.

  • Starts at $3,199 for a Twin Long and goes to $6,398 for a split California King.

Side-By-Side Comparison

 
Casper
TEMPUR-PEDIC
Construction
Airscape Breathable Foam
Tempur Comfort Layer
 
Zoned Support Foam
Tempur Cooling Layer
 
Durable Foam Base
Tempur Base Layer
Price Range
$595-$1295
$1,699-$2,399
Shipping
FREE (except HI and AK)
FREE (except HI and AK)
Sleep Trial
100-night trial
90-night trial
Financing
Affirm
Tempur-Pedic Credit Card
Warranty
10-year warranty
10-year warranty

Both Casper and Tempur-Pedic make memory foam and hybrid mattresses. Casper is a direct-to-consumer brand, shipping their mattresses rolled and compressed in a box straight to your doorstep. However, Tempur-Pedic does offer one bed-in-a-box model as well. While both of these companies are great at making mattresses, there are some striking differences. Casper mattresses are less expensive and don't offer as many options. Tempur-Pedic has a wide range of options but costs thousands of dollars.

While Casper may not use the expansive range of materials that Tempur-Pedic does, that doesn't mean they lack quality or support. Most Casper mattresses are designed for support at the highest level. Casper is a great mattress for those who don't like the hustle of a mattress store or those who need more spine support. Casper isn't for those who like to try before they buy or specifically prefer to not have the support in certain areas.

Tempur-Pedic mattresses are top of the line and are made from materials originally created by NASA. While they're priced substantially higher than Casper, you're getting what you pay for. From cooling technology to support, everything on these mattresses is a step above. However, if you're on a budget or can't justify spending a good chunk of money on a mattress, Tempur-Pedic isn't for you. People with joint problems are a perfect fit for Tempur-Pedic.

How To Choose The Right Mattress

First off, if your current mattress is 7-10 years old and you're experiencing more body aches and pains, it's time to buy a new mattress. Getting a good night's sleep is essential in maintaining a healthy body and mind. Choosing the right mattress doesn't have to be a hassle, follow these guidelines to find the right one for you!

  • Choose a mattress based on your individual needs. If you're looking for plushier support that adapts to your body's shape, a memory foam mattress is the best choice. If you want a more firm, traditional, feel an innerspring mattress is what you want. For the best of both worlds, get a hybrid mattress.
  • Get proper lumbar support. The majority of your body weight is positioned in what is called the "center third" of the mattress. Find a mattress that has excellent lumbar support as it prevents and alleviates pain in the back and hips. If you're looking for extra support, Saatva's unique lumbar zone technology might be the best fit.
  • Find a mattress with a long in-home trial. You want to be able to test your mattress over an extended period of time to really make sure this is the right one for you. Look for a company that offers a risk-free in-home sleep trial. Nectar offers a 365-day trial. IDLE Sleep offers a full 18-month trial (the longest in the industry).

Where can I find a great, affordable mattress (in 2020)?

If you're searching for an affordable mattress that offers a wide range of comfort and pressure relief, we've compiled a list of mattresses for you to consider:

  1. Saatva Mattress - fantastic for all sleep positions, and is rated our Best Mattress of 2020.
  2. Idle Sleep - great for responsive pressure relief.
  3. Puffy - feels like you're sleeping on a cool cloud (at a good price).
  4. Ghostbed - beautiful, plush cover w/ aerated latex and healthy spinal alignment.
  5. Winkbeds - 3-stage back relief with free shipping and returns.

Read our short, well-researched 10 Best Mattresses of 2020, here. Our ultimate goal is to help you pick your perfect mattress online, today!

Get $200 off, purchases over $1000!

Saatva is our top pick for the #1 mattress in 2020! They're a luxury bed shipped directly to your door (with white-glove delivery), and over 50,000 reviews.

Check Price →