Casper vs Puffy

Scott White
Chief Sleep Researcher
Updated 3 Days Ago

The subtly contouring Puffy foam allows ease of movement while the softer Casper foam cushions more closely. Puffy facilitates position changes while Casper provides more focused pressure absorption. Puffy suits combination positions while Casper envelops dedicated side sleepers.

Get $1350 Off
Get 25% Off
Our Rating
Best For
Free Returns
Free Trial
Get $1350 Off
All Sleep Styles
Get 25% Off
10 years
Back Sleeper


Casper's original mattress starts at about $1,000 for a Queen. Puffy's flagship model starts at around $1,150 for a Queen. Both offer premium versions at higher prices.

$595 - $745
$545 - $1,095
Twin XL
$645 - $795
$595 - $1,295
$795 - $945
$895 - $1,495
$895 - $1,045
$995 - $1,695
$1,095 - $1,245
$1,295 - $2,095
California King
$1,650 - $1,950
$1,325 - $2,125

Casper Vs Puffy


Puffy, known for its cloud-like comfort, crafts mattresses that ensure dreamy sleep experiences. Their offerings prioritize adaptability, support, and a touch of luxury.


Offers an impressive range of comfort experiences, ensuring there's a perfect match for all sleep styles and preferences. This customization helps to accommodate pressure areas and cater to various sleeping positions, enhancing overall comfort.

Best for long term support needed by all sleep styles.

Infuses their mattresses with natural materialsl. These natural elements help eliminate harmful toxins and chemical flame retardants.


Casper has made a mark with its innovative designs and exceptional comfort. Each mattress reflects a commitment to sleep science, offering the right blend of support and softness for deep rest.


This model offers more pressure relief compared to its predecessor. It's an excellent choice for those suffering from chronic pain, providing restful, restorative sleep.

Cooling Gel Foam: The mattress includes a cooling gel memory foam layer that efficiently regulates temperature to keep hot sleepers comfortable all night long. The cooling gel foam also contours to the body, providing personalized comfort.

Performs excellently in terms of motion isolation. The design ensures you won't be disturbed by a restless partner, leading to a peaceful night's sleep.

Compare What’s Inside

When you hear "mattress-in-a-box" chances are the first company that pops in your head is Casper. Not only do they make comfortable beds, they're also great at alleviating pressure. We've compiled a side-by-side comparison of Casper's top competitor, Puffy, to see which mattress is the right choice for you.

Casper & Puffy at a glance

Casper is often synonymous with the "mattress-in-a-box concept." They've shipped mattresses to millions of customers since their launch in 2014. It's built with a layer of Zoned Support™ which targets certain areas of your body to ensure proper spinal alignment. What sets Casper is apart is that they're an eco-conscious company—never using harmful materials, sticking to strict environmental standards, and building their mattress covers with recycled materials.

While Casper remains some of the most popular beds nationwide, are they really worth the hype? Let's take a look at Casper and their closest competitor to see which mattress brand reigns supreme.  

Competitor #1: Casper

Casper makes both all-foam and hybrid models in various sizes and firmness levels. They not only offer some of the most affordable bed-in-a-box models, they're also some of the highest-rated among consumers. Here's a closer look at each of their mattresses:


Element is the most basic, most affordable option Casper has to offer. It features a perforated breathable foam that keeps you cool at night and the mattress cover is made with up to 9 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $395 for a Twin and goes up to $795 for a California King


The Original mattress is also their most popular, with 3 zones of support, a perforated breathable foam to keep you cool at night, and the mattress cover is made with up to 57 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $595 for a Twin and goes up to $1295 for a California King

Nova Hybrid

The Nova Hybrid is good for those who want a plush top layer without sacrificing support and cooling. Features 7 zones of support for proper spinal alignment, 2 layers of perforated breathable foam to keep you cool at night, hybrid design for added airlift and support, and the mattress cover is made with up to 70 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $1095 for a Twin and goes up to $2295 for a California King

Wave Hybrid

Features continuous ergonomic zones with gel pods relieve aches and pains, 3 layers of perforated breathable foam to keep you cool at night, hybrid design for added airlift and support, and the mattress cover is made with up to 121 recycled bottles.

  • Starts at $1495 for a Twin and goes up to $2995 for a California King

Competitor #2: Puffy

Puffy features a collection of beds comprised of premium foam and cooling gels. They're designed to provide exceptional comfort, support, and pressure relief.

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Mattress is ideal for all sleeper types. The cooling gel cloud layer in combination with the ClimateComfort™ layer provides optimal temperature control and stabilization. Firm core support foam targets specific aches and pains on the body, and has excellent spinal alignment capabilities, so you wake up feeling rejuvenated. The Zip-N-Wash cover is stain resistant and machine washable, so your mattress stays fresh, longer. Another bonus? The Puffy Mattress can be placed on any surface, including adjustable bed frames and the floor!

  • Starts at $795 for a Twin and goes up to $1350 for a California King

Puffy Lux

Includes everything in the original Puffy Mattress, plus Dual Cloud Foam. Exclusive to the Puffy Lux, the Cooling Cloud and Body Adapting Dual Cloud Foam layers work together to minimize strain from specific pressure points. You wake up feeling more rested and refreshed.

  • Starts at $1445 for a Twin and goes up to $1995 for a California King

Puffy Royal

The newest mattress, Puffy Royal is built with innovative specs for the best in comfort and cooling. The top is features a 1.5-inch cooling layer infused with cooling beads that reduce heat retention on the surface for continuous cooling qualities all night long. A 2-inch premium foam second layer provides reflexive pressure relief to leave you free of aches and pains. The exclusive 5 cloud zone technology provides firm support to your back, and a softer feel for your head, neck, shoulders, and feet. Built with exceptional breathable layers, this mattress stays cool and fresh, giving you an unparalleled comfortable sleep.

  • Starts at $1645 for a Twin and goes up to $2995 for a California King

Side-By-Side Comparison

Both Casper and Puffy are very popular, highly-rated direct-to-consumer mattress companies, but which one has the best mattress?

Casper and Puffy (the original models) are very similar. They both feature a 3-layer all-foam design with excellent targeted pressure point relief, a breathable cover, and medium-firm feel. If low price is your most important factor, the Casper Original is $1095 for a Queen—approximately $100 cheaper than the Queen-sized Puffy Original. If sustainability matters greatly to you, Casper designs each of their mattress covers with recycled bottles. However, one huge difference is their warranties. Casper mattresses are backed by a 10-year warranty, whereas all Puffy beds have a lifetime warranty! If you want peace of mind knowing your bed is guaranteed to last as long as you own it, we suggest you go with Puffy.

How To Choose The Right Mattress

First off, if your current mattress is 7-10 years old and you're experiencing more body aches and pains, it's time to buy a new mattress. Getting a good night's sleep is essential in maintaining a healthy body and mind. Choosing the right mattress doesn't have to be a hassle, follow these guidelines to find the right one for you!

  • Choose a mattress based on your individual needs. If you're looking for plushier support that adapts to your body's shape, a memory foam mattress is the best choice. If you want a more firm, traditional, feel an innerspring mattress is what you want. For the best of both worlds, get a hybrid mattress.
  • Get proper lumbar support. The majority of your body weight is positioned in what is called the "center third" of the mattress. Find a mattress that has excellent lumbar support as it prevents and alleviates pain in the back and hips. If you're looking for extra support, Saatva's unique lumbar zone technology might be the best fit.
  • Find a mattress with a long in-home trial. You want to be able to test your mattress over an extended period of time to really make sure this is the right one for you. Look for a company that offers a risk-free in-home sleep trial. Nectar offers a 365-day trial. IDLE Sleep offers a full 18-month trial (the longest in the industry).

Where can I find a great, affordable mattress (in 2024)?

If you're searching for an affordable mattress that offers a wide range of comfort and pressure relief, we've compiled a list of mattresses for you to consider:

  1. Saatva Mattress - fantastic for all sleep positions, and is rated our Best Mattress of 2024.
  2. Puffy - feels like you're sleeping on a cool cloud (at a good price).
  3. Ghostbed - beautiful, plush cover w/ aerated latex and healthy spinal alignment.
  4. Winkbeds - 3-stage back relief with free shipping and returns.

Read our short, well-researched 10 Best Mattresses of 2024, here. Our ultimate goal is to help you pick your perfect mattress online, today!

What people are saying


The Casper contains softer foam for more of a “sink-in” feel with pressure relief, while the Puffy keeps sleepers on top of the mattress with minimal contouring. The Casper cushions the shoulders and hips of side sleepers better, while the Puffy facilitates movement for combination sleepers. The Casper suits those wanting a bit more “memory foam” hug, while the Puffy works best for those seeking ease of movement.